“Marketing’s leads are garbage” is one of the most common complaints inside any company with both a sales team and a marketing team. It’s rarely actually about the leads. It’s about a trust gap that formed somewhere else and shows up here because this is where the two teams are forced to collide.
The complaint is usually a symptom
When sales says the leads are bad, they often mean something more specific: the leads don’t match what a closed deal has historically looked like, marketing defines “qualified” using criteria sales never agreed to, or the handoff between the two teams loses context that would have made the lead easier to work.
None of that is really about lead quality in the abstract. It’s about two teams operating from different definitions of success, without ever forcing themselves to agree on one.
Why this misalignment persists for so long
Because it’s easier to blame the other team than to fix the actual structural problem. Marketing points to lead volume and campaign performance. Sales points to close rates and pipeline quality. Both scoreboards can be technically accurate and still tell completely different stories, because nobody built a shared definition of what a good lead actually looks like before the finger-pointing started.
What actually closes the gap
A joint definition of a qualified lead, built with both teams in the room, not handed down by marketing alone. Closed-loop reporting that tracks a lead all the way from first touch to closed deal, so both teams are looking at the same data instead of two separate versions of the truth. And a regular cadence — monthly, not just at renewal time — where both teams review what’s actually converting and adjust the definition together.
The uncomfortable step most companies skip
Someone has to own bringing both teams into the same room with the same data and admitting the current system isn’t working. That’s an uncomfortable conversation, and it’s far less costly than the alternative: sales quietly ignoring a growing share of marketing’s leads while marketing keeps reporting volume as if the problem doesn’t exist.
The fix that actually holds
Not a better lead-scoring model built in isolation. A functioning relationship between the two teams, built on a shared scoreboard both sides had a hand in creating. Everything else is a workaround for a trust problem that workaround alone won’t solve.
About the Author
Dan Enrico is the VP of Strategy at DSM, a full-service digital marketing agency based in New Jersey. He leads paid search, paid social, and programmatic strategy for mid-market and enterprise clients, with a focus on connecting media spend directly to pipeline and revenue outcomes rather than surface-level engagement metrics. Dan works closely with client leadership teams to build attribution models that hold up under real scrutiny, turning media performance into decisions the C-suite can actually act on.